More T blocks as we've read them in debates

Extra T vs. IPR

Violation – The plan gives more that assistance – the give generic ARV’s and change patent policy, the change in policy is not necessary to give these drugs.
File Not Found
File Not Found


T assistance vs. IPR

Topical plans must increase the amount of aid that actually gets into the possession of Africa. Assistance means actual giving of something like money, resources, or information.
And to indicates the recipient of the aid.
File Not Found
File Not Found





If you 1. PHA = can't affect one individual or a targeted group, e.g. can't affect only Lake Victoria -
Aff is Fistula - Mike C (NEG)
File Not Found
File Not Found
, Tonia (AFF)
File Not Found
File Not Found


2. Assistance = can't just give information and can't just buy their garbage, must be some "stuff." -
Alex (AFF)
File Not Found
File Not Found
, Sean (NEG)
File Not Found
File Not Found


3. Substantially = can't spec the type of PHA - means w/o mat quals -
Lisa (AFF)
File Not Found
File Not Found
, Leo (NEG)
File Not Found
File Not Found


4. increase = create (gag rule bc we dont do aid for abortions now) -
Elizabeth (AFF)
File Not Found
File Not Found
, Trevor (NEG)
File Not Found
File Not Found


5. increase doesn't change (unrestrict a type of aid - without restrictions) - AFF is remove conditions on aid -
Kristina (NEG)
File Not Found
File Not Found
, Sam P (AFF)
File Not Found
File Not Found


6. can't spec your country -
Mike G (NEG)
File Not Found
File Not Found
, Rob (AFF)
File Not Found
File Not Found


7. PHA is not prevention (such as stopping a nuke war) -
Pavan (NEG)
File Not Found
File Not Found
, Sam H (AFF)
File Not Found
File Not Found


8. T is a voter - Ryan (AFF)
File Not Found
File Not Found
, Robert (NEG)
File Not Found
File Not Found


9. PH is not Public Safety - Aff is Landmines-
Jon (NEG), Risha (AFF)
File Not Found
File Not Found